Start with the two numbers owners rarely write down: total capital in, including the lease and any renewal you committed to, and the nightly rate the villa actually achieves rather than the one on the listing. The remaining seven inputs only work if those two are honest, because every percentage below is applied to them.
Gross yield and ROI are two different numbers
Gross yield is one division: annual rent divided by the price you paid. It is easy to quote and it tells you almost nothing, because every cost line between the guest's payment and the owner's account is missing from it. ROI is the same division done on money that actually reaches you, after the villa has been operated for a full year — and after the finite lease is taken into account.
That difference is why two owners of similar villas can report returns that look nothing alike. They are not measuring the same thing.
| Measure | What goes in the numerator | What it hides |
|---|---|---|
| Gross yield | Annual rent at the listed rate | Commissions, management fee, tax, opening costs, the lease term |
| Net yield | What the owner is actually paid in a year | Nothing important — if every cost line is counted |
| ROI on total capital | Same as net yield, divided by lease, build, furniture and transaction costs | Nothing — if the comparison period is honest |
The formula, in one line
ROI = (annual gross booking revenue − OTA commissions − management fee − hotel tax − staff and operating costs − income tax) ÷ total capital in.
Every input below is either something you can measure or something you have to agree with a manager in writing. If an input exists only as a promise, it does not go into the model.
The nine inputs
1. Total capital in
Not the asking price. Add the lease and any renewal you committed to pay for, the construction or renovation, furniture, pool and garden works, permits, and the transaction costs around the deed. If part of the capital is money you will never see again — renewal fees, permits, furniture depreciation — it belongs in the numerator's denominator too, because ROI is measured against everything the villa consumed.
2. Realistic annual occupancy
Use a month-by-month figure, then a yearly average, and run two scenarios instead of one. Build the base case from twelve months of actual occupancy for this villa or a comparable one, then a pessimistic case below it. We do not publish an average occupancy figure to plug in: it differs widely by villa, area, price and management, and many villas in Bali run at a loss. The gap between the two scenarios is the honest range of your model; the seasonality guide explains which months are usually high and low.
3. Nightly rate you actually achieve
Not the peak-season rate on the listing. Take the average across the year, after long-stay discounts, early-booking discounts and minimum-stay rules. A villa that fills its calendar at a discount is not performing like a villa that fills it at the rack rate, even when the occupancy number is identical.
4. Channel mix and OTA commission
Commission depends on which platform brought the booking, not on the villa. The published rates for 2026 are 14–16% on Airbnb under the host-only model, 15–18% on Booking.com, 15–20% on Agoda and 5–8% on Vrbo; direct bookings cost only payment processing. Enter your intended split between channels, not your best-case one — the comparison is in the OTA commission breakdown.
5. Management fee — and the base it is charged on
Full-service villa management in Bali is usually quoted at 15–30% of rental revenue; booking-only agents sit at about 10–15%. The rate matters less than the base: a management fee on gross revenue is charged on money the OTA already kept, so two quotes with the same percentage can cost very different amounts. Write the base into the model exactly as the contract defines it.
6. Hotel tax
Pajak Hotel is a regional tax levied on the booking, and 10% is the reference rate. Decide once whether the villa absorbs it or the guest pays it on top, and keep that decision consistent through the whole model — mixing the two is the fastest way to inflate a yield by a tenth.
7. Staff and operating costs
Housekeeping, villa manager, pool and garden, AC servicing, utilities, water, internet, consumables, linen replacement, repairs. Under a booking-only arrangement these stay with the owner in full. Under full service, check what is inside the fee and what is invoiced on top — the fee guide lists the usual exclusions, and the staff cost guide covers the payroll side.
8. Income tax
The route decides the base. A non-resident individual is taxed under PPh 26 at 20% of gross rental income, withheld at source; a PT PMA pays 22% of net taxable income and can deduct operating expenses. Which one applies to you changes the result, so the model must name it — details are in the rental income tax guide.
9. Remaining lease term
A leasehold runs down. Amortise the capital over the years that remain, and compare that to what you expect to recover on exit. A villa with fifteen years left cannot be modelled with the same annual return as one with thirty, even if the rent is identical, because the remaining term is part of what you are buying.
A percentage waterfall: what stays with the owner
Take 100 units of gross booking revenue in any currency and subtract the lines in the order they hit the account. The percentages below are the reference ranges published on this site, not a promise about any specific villa.
| Step | Line | Reference range |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gross booking revenue | 100% |
| 2 | OTA commission | minus 5–20%, depending on channel |
| 3 | Management fee | minus 15–30% full service, 10–15% booking-only |
| 4 | Hotel tax | minus 10% of the booking if the villa absorbs it |
| 5 | Staff and operating costs | your own figures, not a percentage of revenue |
| 6 | Income tax | 20% of gross, or 22% of net under a PT PMA |
| 7 | Net cash to the owner | what is left — this is the numerator of ROI |
Two things fall out of that sequence. First, the fee base matters more than the fee rate: a management percentage charged on gross is applied before the OTA and the tax have taken their share. Second, the lines are multiplicative, not additive — a model that subtracts percentages one after another from the same base overstates what remains.
Three mistakes that inflate a Bali villa yield
- Calling gross yield ROI. Annual rent divided by price ignores every operational cost. It is a marketing number, not a return.
- Comparing fee percentages without their base. Two managers quoting the same percentage on gross and on after-commission revenue do not cost the same, and the difference is larger than most owners expect.
- Leaving the lease out. A return calculated on a term you do not have, or on a renewal price you have not agreed in the deed, is a scenario about someone else's asset.
What to ask for before you accept a number
- Twelve months of actual occupancy and achieved nightly rate for this villa or a comparable one — not a seasonal peak.
- The fee definition in writing: rate, base, and what is invoiced on top.
- The tax route: which entity earns the rent, and which withholding applies.
- The remaining lease term and the agreed renewal formula.
- The exit assumption: who buys this lease from you, and with how many years left.
A seller or manager who can produce those five items has given you a model. One who cannot has given you a mood. The wider context — structure, costs, red flags and the legal frame — is in the Bali property investment guide, and the research view sits on the investment page.
Frequently asked questions
What is a realistic ROI for a villa in Bali?
There is no single number, because the answer is the output of nine inputs: occupancy, achieved nightly rate, channel mix, management fee and its base, hotel tax, operating costs, income tax treatment, total capital and the remaining lease. This site publishes the reference ranges for the cost lines so you can build the model yourself rather than adopt a figure someone else calculated on their own assumptions.
Is gross rental yield the same as ROI?
No. Gross yield divides the annual rent at the listed rate by the price. ROI uses what the owner is actually paid after OTA commissions, the management fee, hotel tax, operating costs and income tax, and divides it by the full capital in, including the finite lease term.
What occupancy should go into the model?
Run two: a base case built from twelve months of actual occupancy for this villa or a comparable one, and a pessimistic case below it. We do not publish an average occupancy figure to plug in, because occupancy differs widely by villa, area, price and management, and many villas in Bali run at a loss. The gap between the two scenarios is the honest range of the answer.
Is the management fee charged on gross or net revenue?
It depends on the contract, and it must be checked clause by clause. Full-service management in Bali is usually quoted at 15–30% of rental revenue and booking-only agents at 10–15%, but a fee on gross revenue is charged before the OTA keeps its commission and before tax, so the same percentage can cost materially more than the same percentage on after-commission revenue.
Checking a villa's return before you commit?
Send the villa, the area and the numbers you were quoted, and we will rebuild the model with real occupancy, the fee base and the tax route before you sign anything.